Is search dead?
New SEO Rules, New Game: Marketing Tips for 2025
Is Search Dead?
How SEO Changes Could Reshape Marketing for Small and Medium Businesses
For years, digital marketers and small businesses have operated under an unspoken understanding with Google. The deal was simple: if you created valuable, high-quality content, Google would reward you with traffic.
This wasn’t always easy—the rules changed, and algorithms evolved—but it was manageable. Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) could rely on content and strategic SEO to compete, sometimes even beating out larger brands on certain searches.
Today, however, that “understanding” is eroding as Google shifts its focus to delivering AI-generated answers directly on its search results page. This evolution has huge implications for SMEs, and it’s time to assess what it all means for SEO and marketing strategies.
The Rise of Google's AI-Driven Responses
Historically, Google served as the ultimate connector between users and websites. If your content was high-quality and optimised, Google rewarded you with clicks, potential customers, and exposure.
But today, when a user searches for an answer, Google often provides an AI-generated response directly on the search results page, synthesising information from multiple sources. While this can offer users a quicker answer, it also means they’re less likely to click through to individual websites—depriving businesses of valuable traffic.
This shift represents a new reality: the focus is no longer on driving traffic to external websites but on keeping users within Google’s ecosystem.
For SMEs that once relied on organic search visibility, this change means that traditional SEO strategies may not yield the same results as before.
Businesses must now think beyond rankings and clicks, focusing on direct ways to connect with their audience and adding value beyond what AI-generated responses can provide.
The Evolution of SEO: Keywords, Links, and Snippets
Google’s approach to ranking content has continuously evolved.
Initially, it was all about keywords—businesses scrambled to include as many as possible, leading to “keyword stuffing,” which Google soon penalised.
Next, backlinks became the gold standard; if other reputable sites linked to your content, Google rewarded you with higher rankings. The era of backlinks, however, introduced the problem of “link farms,” where sites would trade or sell links to artificially inflate SEO rankings.
With the rise of mobile searches and voice commands Google pivoted yet again, prioritising semantic search and natural language understanding.
This update was aimed at accommodating voice searches and more complex queries, pushing businesses to create content that was conversational and responsive to real-world questions.
The next SEO frontier, however, isn’t about matching keywords or links; it’s about creating answers to users’ questions—preferably ones that are personalised and add depth that an AI might miss.
For example, rather than competing on broad topics, an SME might now find more success with hyper-targeted, niche content that AI may not yet be trained to deliver effectively.
How Big Retailers Take Over—and What SMEs Can Do
When users search for products, large companies like Amazon or Takealot dominate search results, often pushing smaller businesses down the rankings. This dominance is compounded by AI-generated product descriptions, shopping carousels, and links to large, trusted e-commerce sites.
It’s no surprise, then, that many small businesses are struggling to compete in this space.
What smaller businesses need to recognise is that while they can’t outspend these giants on advertising or SEO, they can leverage something invaluable: personal connection.
Unlike national brands that are recognized by logo and reputation, SMEs have the flexibility to engage directly, build authentic customer relationships, and make their clients feel valued in ways that big businesses can’t easily replicate.
The Decline of the "Mom-and-Pop" Store: Lessons from Local Markets
Take a walk through many South African shopping malls, and the evidence is clear: the landscape has shifted dramatically.
Independent boutiques that once thrived on unique offerings and customer relationships are vanishing, replaced by large chain stores. And while some big retailers like Pick n Pay and Edgars have had to adapt or downsize, smaller stores have been forced to innovate more rapidly to survive.
This trend is instructive for SMEs in the digital space: survival requires adaptation. For those SMEs that can’t rely on traditional SEO and foot traffic, digital marketing efforts should prioritise unique value and personalised customer experiences. By offering exclusive deals, targeted content, and engaging email newsletters, smaller businesses can nurture customer loyalty in ways that big corporations can’t.
Leveraging Your "Superpowers" to Build Customer Relationships
When it comes to relationship-building, SMEs have an edge. They can provide personalised interactions, cater to niche customer bases, and communicate directly with clients.
Here are a few ways SMEs can leverage these advantages in a digital landscape increasingly shaped by AI:
- Personalized Content: Offer content tailored to your clients’ specific interests and needs. This could mean sharing industry insights, hosting local events, or addressing specific challenges that your audience faces.
- Consistent Communication: A well-crafted email newsletter, such as those created with MailJam, can keep your audience engaged and informed about new offerings, exclusive deals, and valuable insights.
- Community Engagement: Encourage customers to engage with you on social media, leave reviews, and participate in your online events. Building a community around your brand strengthens loyalty.
- Customer Service: Provide a high level of service by being accessible, responsive, and attentive to your customers’ needs. Small businesses can excel here, offering a personal touch that AI-driven customer service bots simply can’t replicate.
Implementing Relationship-Driven Marketing
Rather than merely aiming to rank on Google, SMEs need to make their audience feel appreciated and valued. Here’s a roadmap for implementing relationship-driven marketing:
- Start with Email Marketing: A newsletter can provide consistent, valuable touchpoints with customers. Mailjam is a great option for creating visually appealing, personalized newsletters that resonate with your audience.
- Embrace Content That Google Can’t Replicate: Dive deep into storytelling, case studies, and narratives that showcase your expertise and build trust with customers. AI can summarize facts but lacks the nuance to tell a compelling brand story.
- Build Local SEO: Focusing on local SEO can help you reach customers who are searching for nearby services. This could involve listing your business in local directories, optimising your Google My Business profile, and encouraging satisfied customers to leave positive reviews.
- Create Engaging Social Media Content: Use social media to build relationships, share behind-the-scenes stories, and create interactive experiences like Q&A sessions or live product demonstrations.
The Future of SEO and Marketing for SMEs
The SEO landscape is shifting fast, and SMEs must adapt or risk being left behind. As Google continues to focus on AI and larger corporations monopolise product listings, smaller businesses can succeed by focusing on what they do best: building personal connections and offering niche value. The advantage of a small business lies in its ability to pivot quickly, build genuine relationships, and respond to customer needs with a personal touch that is hard to scale.
Embrace the Change, Leverage the Connection
While the days of easy SEO wins may be over, the shift toward AI presents an opportunity for SMEs to refocus on direct customer engagement. If your business can harness the power of relationship-driven marketing, you’ll not only survive but thrive. Start by exploring tools like MailJam for your newsletters, connect directly with your audience, and give your customers reasons to choose you over larger, impersonal brands.
The future belongs to those who can adapt and embrace new strategies—by connecting authentically, your small business can build resilience in the face of technological disruption.
Digitally First but Physically Enhanced
The Online Business Model has usurped the Physical Business Presence as the primary business presence. Physical businesses now support the online versions.
This transitioning has been fraught with difficulty but has been terribly exciting. Successful transients are alive with possibilities…
New SEO Rules, New Game: Marketing Tips for 2025 Read More »
Connect with your target market, Your Online Presence